fallacy finder

false dilemma fallacy

only two options

what it is

Presents a choice as if there were only two possibilities when there are clearly more. Usually one option is made to look terrible so the other wins by default.

an example

"Either we cut the arts program or the school goes bankrupt."

Why it does not hold up. Budgets have many levers. Framing it as one cut or ruin hides all of them.

how fallacy finder spots it

Your text is split into sentences, and Jev is asked this about each one:

Does this line present only two options as if they were the only possibilities, when other options plausibly exist?

  • Counts as false dilemma when it frames an either/or choice that leaves out reasonable alternatives.
  • Does not count when it does not force a binary choice, or the two options really are exhaustive.

Jev answers with a probability. A line gets a solid underline at 60% or higher and a dotted one from 50%. The same sentence is checked for the seven other fallacies at the same time, and one line can carry more than one.

check your own textPaste an argument and see which lines use false dilemma.

other fallacies