fallacy finder

strawman fallacy

distorts the other view

what it is

Restates the other side as a weaker, cruder or more extreme version of what they said, then knocks that version down. The real position never gets answered.

an example

"He wants fewer cars downtown. So he wants to ban everyone from driving to work."

Why it does not hold up. Fewer cars and a total ban are very different proposals. Only the second one is easy to mock.

how fallacy finder spots it

Your text is split into sentences, and Jev is asked this about each one:

Does this line misrepresent or exaggerate an opposing position so it is easier to attack?

  • Counts as strawman when it attributes a distorted, exaggerated or oversimplified view to the other side and argues against that.
  • Does not count when it represents opposing views fairly or does not characterise anyone else's view.

Jev answers with a probability. A line gets a solid underline at 60% or higher and a dotted one from 50%. The same sentence is checked for the seven other fallacies at the same time, and one line can carry more than one.

check your own textPaste an argument and see which lines use strawman.

other fallacies