what it is
Answers a criticism by pointing at somebody else's wrongdoing instead of responding to it. The original point is left standing but the conversation moves on.
an example
"Sure, our factory leaks, but what about the plant across the river?"
Why it does not hold up. The other plant being bad does not make this leak any cleaner.
how fallacy finder spots it
Your text is split into sentences, and Jev is asked this about each one:
Does this line deflect a criticism by pointing to someone else's faults instead of addressing the criticism?
- Counts as whataboutism when it changes the subject to another party's wrongdoing to avoid answering a point.
- Does not count when it responds to the point directly, or raises a comparison that is genuinely relevant.
Jev answers with a probability. A line gets a solid underline at 60% or higher and a dotted one from 50%. The same sentence is checked for the seven other fallacies at the same time, and one line can carry more than one.